Navigating Succession Planning in Family Businesses
Updated: Oct 2
Understanding the Complexity of Succession
Succession isn’t just a legal process, handover, or change of job titles. It’s a shift in identity. A transition of power. A series of moments where relationships, expectations, and legacy collide.
Succession is where many ambitious family-run SMEs struggle—often simply because alignment hasn’t been built properly first.
No matter how strong the business is currently or how capable the individuals leading it are, without strategic alignment across the different family members, the business will lose momentum at the very moment it should be preparing to take the next big leap.
If this is a pain you're feeling, defining shared foundations is a good place to start.
Not Dysfunctional but Complex
Family businesses are built with a level of emotional investment that most big businesses can only dream of. They have the potential to be as strong as any other—in some ways, stronger. But the very strengths that make them special can also cause huge challenges.
The Upsides of Family Businesses
Deep trust and loyalty
Long-term thinking (in theory)
Pride in product, service, and community
A built-in sense of a shared 'something special'
A founder’s resilience that can shape the culture
The Challenges
Unspoken expectations
Different generations with different priorities
Decision-making based on personality, not strategy (hello, nepotism!)
Personal agendas compromising business agendas
Lack of diversity leading to "groupthink" with narrow perspectives and low innovation levels
Resistance to change (“This is how we’ve always done it”)
Firefighting becoming the default operating mode
It's these challenges that cause many consultants to run a mile from working with a family business—citing them as 'dysfunctional' or 'difficult to work with'. But not Rock.Partners.
Rock's founder, Rachel Vigers, witnessed firsthand the complex dynamic in her own family business—which, at various stages, comprised her father, one or two of her three brothers, and (very briefly and dysfunctionally) her uncle.
In addition, over the course of her career, Rachel has provided strategic business or brand support to several family businesses in various sectors, including retail, entertainment, utilities, consultancy/training, travel, tourism, and financial services. In her words...
"With family businesses, succession planning is one trigger that keeps on firing."
What Stops Succession Going Smoothly?
Two of the biggest barriers to smooth succession in family businesses are misplaced priorities and resistance to change.
1. Misplaced Priorities
Non-family businesses (at least those that manage their talent well) tend to hire based on skillset, capabilities, attitude, and cultural fit. In theory, the right people are recruited for the right roles, and the strength of the business as a whole is the main priority. When clashes arise, they can be managed appropriately—sometimes requiring an individual to leave the business.
In family businesses, priorities can get muddled. This means individuals, even senior executives, can be recruited based on bloodline or relationship alone, regardless of their ability to adequately perform the role or fit with the business's goals and culture. If a family hire isn't working, but blood is considered thicker than business, there's no easy way to resolve the problem.
When the relationship between individuals matters more than the business as a whole, that misplaced allegiance can be detrimental to all parties. Key relationships are guarded like badges of honour. Customers are targeted based on who-knows-who, not whether they're a good fit. Hiring decisions become nepotistic, communication is compromised, and the brand ends up undermined.
In a battle between "Family" and "Business," no one's going to win.
It's not about saying business beats family or vice versa. Without prioritising the business's needs, the family risks not having a business to pass on to future generations.
2. Resistance to Change
Every business naturally develops and evolves over time. If they don't, they fail. It's easy for business, brand, and behaviour to fall out of sync.
However, when next-gen leaders enter the fray, bringing bold new perspectives and seeing different opportunities, it can create a culture shift with seismic implications.
Tapping into the next generation's mindset, skills, and ambitions should be an area where family businesses have an advantage. But if there's been little change at a senior level for a long time, convention and habit can feel far more comfortable than intention and adaptation.
In this situation, younger generations may not feel comfortable raising their ideas with the incumbent family members for fear of causing upset or offense. Sometimes, they do speak out, only to be met with a wall of resistance—the age-old mentality of "that's not how we do things around here!"
And what about the rest of the business, who perhaps aren't part of the family and find themselves witnesses to a widening strategic and cultural chasm? Succession is a tricky time for them too. Depending on how well the business is doing at the time, the rest of the team may be crying out for a long-overdue change or, alternatively, feeling seriously apprehensive about what's ahead!
In either case, stability, confidence, and hope need to be demonstrated by the business leaders.
Succession planning should be a welcome opportunity to take stock, to bring fresh perspectives and insights into the business—all within the business's best interests. Sometimes, though, the only family members who get to succeed to senior positions are the ones that don't rock the boat.
This is dangerous because change is unavoidable. Narrow or nostalgic perspectives can lead to a distorted sense of the current business reality or its potential.
Times change, markets move, and customers move on. Trends shift, and technology never stops. If you don't acknowledge it and adapt or react to it, you'll get left behind.
It's not that either generation is inherently right or wrong. It's more about finding common ground to build on.
Why Rock's Way Works
Unfortunately, most family businesses only realise they lack strategic alignment when succession is already on the table. By then, emotions are high, timelines are short, and the stakes are heavy. Bringing in independent strategic support, with the business's best interests at heart, is one way to reduce tensions and increase focus.
One Strategy - No Silos
Rock's distinctive approach is different from most strategic advisers.
We focus on four core foundations—Direction, Connection, Impact, and Value.
Why? Because these are straightforward success factors that everyone can sign up to—regardless of role, experience, seniority, or relationship. They form a common ground for business, brand, and behaviour to be built strategically—strong and in sync.
Through working with Rock.Partners, you'll end up with a clear, robust framework that everyone in your business can follow. This ensures you're all pulling in the same direction, not a dozen different ones!
Think of your family business like a choir, with your foundations strategy being the song-sheet that everyone sings to. It provides a clear, relatable structure to help support decision-making and hold everything steady in the face of change. For family businesses, there are few changes as significant as succession!
In Your Business's Best Interests
But it's not just the output that works—it's the process too.
When defining a company's foundations, Rock takes a robust, balanced, and consultative approach:
We do our homework—researching your sector and competitors to provide additional data points.
We talk to your team—not just management and family members but a cross-representative sample of people who work for you, across every department and at every level. This is especially important in family businesses where non-family members can feel "out-of-the-loop."
We can even talk to your clients, partners, advisers, or key suppliers to gain their insights and perspectives.
Plus, of course, we bring our own independent perspective and expertise that holds a mirror up to your business.
While we'll carefully consider all of the diverse data points and perspectives, our ultimate priority will always be what's best for the business as a whole.
Throughout it all, we'll bring you on the journey—listening and learning right alongside us. It's not unusual for Rock's clients to shift mindsets completely—from resisting or feeling uncomfortable about change to embracing it with confidence and enthusiasm.
Rock's Ready for You!
If you’re a founder or director of a family-owned SME and succession is becoming a conversation (or a concern!), Rock is ready for you.
Drop us a DM at info@rock.partners or get a GRIT Session booked in.
About Us
Led by experienced Business and Brand Consultant, Rachel Vigers, Rock.Partners works with a broad sector client base of owner-managed SMEs determined to build stronger businesses and brands without having to die on a strategic hill in the process!
We help businesses and brands to get strong, stay strong, and exit strong through:
Foundations Strategy: Getting clarity on Direction, Connection, Impact, and Value through Managed or Guided programmes:
- FAST Foundations strategy sprints and workshops
- FIRM Foundations strategy programmes, including research and consultation
- Training, Coaching, and Mentoring for self-delivered strategic programmes
Alignment Support: Mentoring, training, and programme delivery support across commercial, creative, and cultural workflows, partner outsourcing, and management. Our wide partner network, combined with Rock's in-house capabilities, allows us to coordinate everything from setting OKRs to financial modelling, from restructuring service packages to full repositioning and rebrands, from internal engagement to executive coaching.
Comments